Clear notifications ×
Profile Logout
Login
Gizmodo
  • Blog View
  • Top Stories
  • Latest
  • Popular
  • Search
Please confirm your birth date:

Please enter a valid date
Please enter your full birth year
This content is restricted.
apple steve jobs apple htc lawsuit htc lawsuits legal patents patent iphone phones iphones irony
Edit Republish Roundup
Admin ×
Edit Set to Draft Edit syndicated post Invite

Syndicate

Syndicate this post


Site:
Mode:

sending request
By Brian Barrett Mar 2, 2010 2:13 PM 36,768 219
Share this post×
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Tumblr
  • Instapaper
  • Email this post
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Newsletter
Get the most popular stories and breaking news directly in your Twitter feed Follow @Gizmodo
sending request
Please enter your email address.
Please enter a valid email address.

Steve Jobs, 1996: "Good Artists Copy, Great Artists Steal"

Oh, hello! A trip to the YouTube wayback machine shows that 1996's Steve "Great Artists Steal" Jobs might have taken issue with Steve Jobs 2010, and his patent lawsuit firebombing of HTC. Irony!

The comment was made during a 1996 PBS documentary called "Triumph of the Nerds," and looks a smidge hypocritical in light of today's events. As does this one:

"We have always been shameless about stealing great ideas."

Goodness. If that's true, then lawyering up against innovative competitors must be the one of the best ideas you ever heard.

In fact, compare the above to what Jobs said just today in the press release about the HTC lawsuit:

"We can sit by and watch competitors steal our patented inventions, or we can do something about it. We've decided to do something about it. We think competition is healthy, but competitors should create their own original technology, not steal ours."

Emphasis added. That's quite a 180 for a company and a man who have always been known for respecting and triumphing innovation. A disappointing one, at that.

Update: To clarify, and as is clear in the video, Jobs was quoting Pablo Picasso in the headlined quote. The follow-up quote is all him.

There's also a clear distinction between yesterday's statement, which concerns actual, literal patents Apple owns, versus the more general, in-the-ether ideas Jobs references in the video. The Picasso quote speaks to the idea that innovators borrow ideas and an incorporate them into their own work: in this case, he meant that Apple's designers and engineers took all manor of life experiences and used them to make Apple products fresh and innovative. As opposed to the "stealing" he referenced in the press release, which is literally taking a patented technology that somebody owns.

As a company, Apple has consistently been fair in licensing technologies it's found useful or interesting (though Nokia may beg to differ). Has HTC? The lawyers will figure that out, and when they do I look forward to 2015 Steve Jobs's take on it. [YouTube via commenter Fractal the Meek]

Related Stories
  • Apple Already Planning Third Campus

  • HTC Arms Itself With Patents From Google, Strikes Back At Apple (Updated)

  • Why Is Apple Suing a Chinese Food Company for Stealing LG's Logo?

×
Move comment Admin page Edit comment Demote comment sending request
Move thread ×
User action
Thread action
  

Discussion Threads
  • Featured
  • All
  • Start a new thread
Show earlier discussions
Show all discussions Show promoted discussions only
Newer Stories…
  • shoes 413 139,831 The Nike Air Mag—AKA the Back to the Future Shoes—Are Real, and They’re Glorious
  • watch this 409 14,908 Watch Michael J. Fox Show Off the Nike Air Mag on Letterman
  • nasa 114 16,435 A 6.5-Ton Satellite Will Fall To Earth Soon
  • 9/11 113 60,755 These 9/11 Airline Recordings Are the Most Horrifying Thing I’ve Heard
  • sex 93 18,202 A Machine That Collects Tax from Prostitutes
  • lego 88 7,148 How To Race A Lego Car At 25MPH
  • monster machines 87 32,255 How the Greenest Skyscraper Ever Is Rising Out of the Rubble of the World Trade Center
  • cars 82 66,526 The Most Horrific Traffic in the Entire World
  • google 67 30,853 Google Uses More Power Than Salt Lake City
  • architecture 61 19,928 This Is the First Mobile Building In the World
  • cancer 59 40,028 Cuba’s Lung Cancer Vaccine Could Save Your Life
  • craigslist 58 65,394 Advertising a Fake Craigslist Orgy at Your Neighbor’s House Is the Best Revenge
  • jeans 58 23,995 Levi’s Commuter Jeans Lightning Review: Skinny Jeans with Biking Powers
  • iphone 51 11,428 Hey Kids, the iPhone Will NOT Cure Acne
  • how to 50 42,483 Scrub Your PC Clean: Remove Malware in Four Easy Steps
  • energy 44 17,851 Millions in California, Arizona and Mexico Without Power
  • rip 44 10,191 The Father of the eBook Is Dead
  • science 42 2,701 A Social Network Based On Your Gastrointestinal Bacteria
  • dogs 41 6,740 A Dog With Dumbo-Sized Ears
  • energy 36 6,798 A Trippy Turbine Adorned With Lights
  • iphone 33 19,069 Prisoners Don’t Like to Put iPhones Up Their Ass
  • iphone apps 30 8,994 Google Music Comes to iOS with a Pretty Decent Web App
  • 9/11 30 27,546 Take a Close Look at These 9/11 Artifacts
  • watch this 28 40,014 Crazy Guy Puts Out a Fire With a Vacuum Cleaner
  • astronomy 28 40,714 The Moon Like You Have Never Seen It Before
  • apple 28 15,237 Apple Already Planning Third Campus
More Stories…
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 5,591 Gather Up the Slumber Party Posse and Play Would You Rather
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 17,377 Words with Friends Exists Because of John Mayer’s Twitter Account (R.I.P.)
  • Sponsored contest 3:59 PM 8,718 Win the Ultimate Survival Tool
  • Sponsored contest 11:59 AM 5,094 We Did Lollapalooza, Now We Need You for Austin City Limits
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 7,019 “Choose Your Own Adventure” For Grownups Is Actually Just Called Life
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 11,722 Now’s Your Chance to Seal the Deal
  • Sponsored 3:59 PM 20,373 A Whole New Way to Floss
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 6,025 Get More Stars for Less Money! LogMeIn Ignition’s 5-Star Sale
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 7,673 Hop on the Googarola Train for Less than $70
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 24,059 The Bad News Is That You Might Have Missed an Incredible Deal Last Week
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 10,519 The Only Particle Physics-Based Phone You Need
  • Sponsored 12:29 PM 4,093 This Is the Gizmodo Reader Correspondent Reporting Live from Lollapalooza 2011
  • Sponsored contest 11:59 AM 5,225 Want to E-Read Your Summer Away?
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 14,150 Time Is Ticking for Christina Perasso
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 3,719 Personalize all your iDevices and Maptops with the Help of the Gawker Artists Back to School Sale
  • Sponsored contest 11:59 AM 9,151 Win the Ultimate Survival Tool
  • Sponsored 3:59 PM 8,142 Butt Kits, Drone Planes and Sneaky Light Switches Are All It Takes To Be a Secret Agent
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 10,286 How To Maximize Your (Beverage’s) Life Expectancy
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 7,376 Experience What It’s Really Like to Operate a Drone Helicopter
  • Sponsored 11:59 AM 6,702 Christina Perasso Needs You. Now.
  • Sponsored contest 12:00 PM 4,568 Calling All Music Fans/Unabashed Oversharers: Be Gizmodo’s Lollapalooza Correspondent
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 9,859 Only You Can Save Emmy Rossum Using Facebook
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 11,707 Breaking Bad is Going to Get Really Good Tonight
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 11,557 Breaking Bad is About to Get Really Good
  • Sponsored contest 12:00 PM 10,029 Blind Item: Which Techies Have Seriously Broken Bad Recently?
  • Sponsored contest 4:00 PM 4,683 Win Some Wireless, Waterproof Speakers With Which To Practice Sub-Aquatic Vocal Resonation
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 65,807 Nobody Died on the Gawker HQ Roof Last Thursday
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 72,325 Report: Masked Beings Hold "Strange Marches" Across US, Distribute Black Globes
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 29,408 "Soulless" Rumored to Be Gathering Across the Country for Miracle Day Protests
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 15,970 Starred Commenters! Toast the End of the World as We Know It With Us
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 11,376 Save $100 on One of the Most Rugged Hard Drives on the Market
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 8,016 Development of a Great App: Instagram
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 9,461 It’s Time for You to Embrace Modernity with the HTC EVO™ 3D
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 4,971 Save on the Perfect Phone for the Dad that Can’t be Tied Down
  • Sponsored 4:00 PM 9,785 iRobot Roomba 700 Series: So Much More than a Cat Vehicle
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 5,909 Back By Popular DEWmand: Last of the Low-tech Upgrades
  • Sponsored contest 12:00 PM 3,950 Find Out Who Will Continue to Save Lives with the Help of a New Energizer Inductive Charger
  • Sponsored 4:00 PM 15,538 Let’s Go Back to Atari’s Golden Age
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 3,931 Forgot Father’s Day? Make Up for It with an Exclusive Red AT&T HTC Inspire 4G
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 10,220 The Sharp AQUOS Quattron LC-70LE732U Is Seriously Spectacularge
  • Sponsored contest 4:00 PM 3,010 Firefighter, Tornado Survivor, or Big Rig Driver?
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 5,191 Save 10% on a Very Practical Gift for Dad
  • Sponsored contest 4:00 PM 12,408 Stop Torrenting Things Like a Dirty, Dirty Pirate
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 51,378 5 Ways To Keep Your Dad From Being That Guy
  • Sponsored 4:00 PM 9,790 Get a New Perspective with the 18-270MM Di II VC PZD Lens from Tamron
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 5,071 Save $150 When You Join the Cause to Help Dad Take Great Pictures…Finally
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 4,962 Microsoft Office Web Apps Thinks Oversharing Is a Good Thing
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 9,139 Gizmodo Presents: Perfect Presents for Father’s Day (and the Grad in Your Life)
  • Sponsored contest 4:00 PM 5,045 Which of These Heroes with Cell Phones Should Win an Energizer Inductive?
  • Sponsored 12:00 PM 5,718 Back by Popular DEWmand: More Modern Mods
  • About
  • Help
  • Forums
  • Jobs
  • Legal
  • Privacy
  • Permissions
  • Advertising
  • Subscribe
  • Send a tip
%userName% starred %you% %userName% took away %your% star %userName% promoted %your% comment %userName% demoted %your% comment %userName% replied to %your% comment %userName% approved %you% %userName% took away %your% approval %userName% has banned %you% %userName% sent you a message
%text%
You have %count% new notification%notifplural%, click to view
track
Powered by the Parse.ly Publisher Platform (P3).